The Old Testament's portrayal of divorce is complex, often viewed through the lens of modern sensibilities that differ significantly from the cultural and societal norms of ancient Israel. Understanding the context surrounding divorce in the Old Testament requires exploring the historical, legal, and theological aspects of the time. This nuanced perspective allows us to appreciate the complexities of the issue and avoid simplistic interpretations.
What Does the Old Testament Say About Divorce?
The Old Testament doesn't explicitly condone divorce, but it does acknowledge and regulate it. Deuteronomy 24:1-4 is often cited as the primary passage regarding divorce: "If a man marries a woman and she becomes displeasing to him because he finds something indecent about her, and he writes her a certificate of divorce and gives it to her and sends her away from his house…she may go and be another man’s wife." This passage, however, doesn't necessarily imply God's approval but rather provides a legal framework within a patriarchal society to address a broken marriage. The "indecent thing" is left undefined, leaving room for various interpretations and potential abuses.
The key is to recognize this is a legal framework, not a moral endorsement. The law aimed to protect the woman from being held indefinitely in an undesirable marriage, allowing her some agency and preventing potential disputes. This perspective contrasts sharply with later interpretations that saw the passage as a permission slip for men to discard their wives.
Why Did God Allow Such a Legal Framework?
Several factors contributed to God's allowance of divorce within this legal framework:
-
Cultural Context: The Old Testament reflects the social realities of its time. Divorce was common in the ancient Near East, and regulating it was a way of mitigating its harshest consequences for women. Completely prohibiting divorce might have been impractical or even detrimental, leading to greater injustices. God worked within the existing framework, gradually moving towards a higher standard.
-
Progressive Revelation: The Old Testament represents a progressive revelation of God's character and will. As humanity developed, so did God's expectations. The later prophetic books and the New Testament portray a more stringent view of marriage and divorce, reflecting a greater understanding of God's ideal for marital relationships. The Old Testament's legal framework provided a stepping stone on this path towards a more complete understanding of marriage.
-
Protection of Women: While seemingly paradoxical, the law in Deuteronomy could offer a measure of protection to women. Without a legal framework, a woman facing a broken marriage might have been left vulnerable, with no recourse or support. The certificate of divorce at least granted her a degree of legal standing and the possibility of remarriage.
Wasn't Divorce Against God's Ideal for Marriage?
Absolutely. The Old Testament consistently presents marriage as a sacred covenant between a man and a woman, mirroring the covenant relationship between God and Israel. The ideal, portrayed throughout the creation narrative and reflected in many love poems and songs, is a lifelong union characterized by love, fidelity, and mutual commitment. However, the reality often fell short of this ideal, and God dealt with this reality within the limits of the culture's understanding.
What About Malachi 2:16?
Malachi 2:16 is another relevant passage: "For I hate divorce,” says the Lord God of Israel, “and him who covers his garment with violence,” says the Lord of hosts. “So take heed to your spirit, that you do not deal treacherously.” This verse explicitly states God's hatred of divorce, highlighting the discrepancy between God's ideal and the harsh reality of divorce in ancient Israel. This verse underscores the fact that the legal provisions didn't represent God's ideal but rather a pragmatic response within a flawed society.
In Conclusion:
The Old Testament's approach to divorce is a complex interplay of legal necessity, cultural context, and a progressive revelation of God's character. While divorce was permitted under certain circumstances, it never represented God's ultimate intention for marriage. Understanding this historical context is essential for avoiding simplistic interpretations and appreciating the gradual unfolding of God's plan for human relationships.
